2021

2021
DARURAT COVID-19

BERTINDAK SEMBERONO MEMAKAN DIRI

Khamis, Januari 15, 2009

| | |
[Israel mengebom bandar Gaza. Sumber: BBC News 14 Januari 2009]

“Amerika mesti diajar kerana keangkuhannya menaja keganasan Israel di Gaza. Barangan dan perkhidmatan Amerika mesti diboikot. Dengan berbuat demikian raksasa Amerika dapat ditundukkan dan kebiadapan Yahudi dapat dibalas.”

Namun Profesor Emeritus Datuk Dr Mohammed Ariff, Pengarah Eksekutif Institut Penyelidikan Ekonomi Malaysia, berpendapat sebaliknya. Bagi beliau, bertindak dalam kemarahan selalunya semberono dan boleh merugikan diri sendiri.

Dr Mohammed Ariff: “Decisions taken in anger are often wrong, as they are not rationally made based on a careful analysis of the pros and cons. One such decision is to boycott American and Israeli products. No doubt, such boycotts do have symbolic value in sending strong messages, but one must be mindful of the unintended effects, which can be very detrimental.

For starters, consumers who boycott limit their choices, settling for inferior or costlier substitutes, which means they deny themselves value for money. They hurt themselves in trying to hurt the producers of the boycotted products.

Second, it is morally wrong to punish the producers who hardly have anything to do with the policies of the countries they originate from or operate in.

Third, inadvertently, local workers employed by these companies in the host country will eventually bear their brunt of such boycotts.

Fourth, boycotts represent a double-edged sword as they invite retaliation, putting a country's own products at grave risk in export markets.

Fifth, the multinational corporations, which are usually targeted, are often a voice of moderation in their home countries, as they are affected by foreign policies pursued by their home governments.

Sixth, such actions may impede investment inflows by sending the wrong message to potential foreign investors.

The list may go on and on, but the upshot in a nutshell is that a country may end up as net loser without achieving the main objective, namely justice for the Palestinians.

 [Sumber: Time to dispel media untruths about Palestine dalam NST Online 15 Januari 2009]